Is it Pressed Glass or Cut Glass?

OK, so I have a ton of glass from the Janvier Road bungalow. We poured lemonade from it, drank from it, served fruit and potato salad in it. My mom told me there was a difference between pressed and cut glass, but it all looked the same to me.

“How can you tell?” I asked my mom.

“The cut glass is sharper.”

Oh, OK. And that’s where things stood until years later, when I began to realize what I had. And I’m so thankful we rescued it when we sold the bungalow land.

Why, I wasn’t even using the correct terms!
“Cut glass” is “American Brilliant cut glass” or  “American Brilliant Period” (ABP) glass, and the “pressed” stuff is “Early American Pattern Glass” (EAPG).

Which is which? I’m learning that it isn’t always easy to tell.
It might take me years to get it all straight! But in the meantime, I’ll share what I learn as I learn it. In fact, I just ordered what reviewers claim is the best book on identifying EAPG patterns. Perhaps that will help me separate the EAPG from the Brilliant. I hope.

American Brilliant Cut Glass.
It’s “lead crystal,” made with very pure silica and potash, plus at least 40% lead oxide to keep the glass exceptionally clear and keep it from shattering when cut. (Prior to lead, flint was used – but that’s a whole other kind of glass.)

After the glass was blown or poured into a plain mold, skilled craftspeople cut sharp, deep designs into the glass using rotating wheels. Any mold lines were carefully polished away.

The end result is gorgeous.
What happens to light as it passes through a fine piece of brilliant glass is breathtaking and something you must see to appreciate. And when Americans saw it at the 1876 Centennial Exposition in Philadelphia, they couldn’t get enough of it.

9” Star Pattern American Brilliant Bowl Photo courtesy of Treehouse Antiques

9” Star Pattern American Brilliant Bowl
Photo courtesy of Treehouse Antiques

Everyone who was anyone – including the President – used Brilliant glass, much of it designed for special foods, such as bananas, fruits and celery. My grandparents even got some pieces when they built the summer bungalow. Then World War I came along, and the popularity of American Brilliant waned because the materials and artisans were needed for the war effort.

American Brilliant Nappy, Possibly Fry, Circa 1900s.

American Brilliant Nappy, Possibly Fry, Circa 1900s.

Early American Pattern Glass (EAPG).
Basically, much of EAPG is American Brilliant Cut glass for the masses, and most was made during approximately the same period (1850 – 1910).
Molten glass was pressed into molds patterned with many of the same motifs as their more expensive cousins. This method produced lovely glass that was far more affordable. But, because the patterns are so similar to those of American Brilliant, and because companies became good at polishing the mold lines and adding some hand-etched touches, telling EAPG from American brilliant (and the later Elegant Glass) can often be tricky.

How to tell the difference.
Even some experts may struggle deciding whether a piece is EAPG or Brilliant. But these are the major differences that will help you get started.

    • American Brilliant doesn’t have mold marks. EAPG has very thin raised lines where molten glass filled the gap where the mold parts come together. Be careful, because some mold lines are cleverly hidden by part of the pattern. You may feel them on the inside of the piece.
    • Cut glass patterns are sharply defined. EAPG’s details are often slightly blurred.
No mold lines, sharp cuts - and it flouresces under black light. Yet it's probably EAPG. It pays to visit a museum in order to familiarize yourself with Brilliant vs. EAPG.

It flouresces under black light and has some sharp edges, but it’s EAPG. Contrast this little bowl with the nappy above. It pays to visit a museum in order to familiarize yourself with Brilliant vs. EAPG.

  • Cut glass patterns may have slight irregularities, since they were fashioned by hand.
  • Pressed glass may have slight dimples on the inside that mirror the pattern on the outside.
  • Older pieces containing lead are said to glow yellow-green when placed under black light. (Lead was phased out around 1864, when it was needed for the Civil War.)
  • McKee’s “Prescut” and Imperial’s Nucut are EAPG, not American Brilliant, even though they look and feel like cut glass. And McKee’s “Innovation” line also added hand-cut detailing to the pressed mold glass.
  • And yes, cut glass feels “sharper” when you run your fingers over it. Pressed glass may look hand-cut, but the points will be much smoother. The other day, I unpacked another box of items to list on Etsy. I unwrapped the nappy shown above. Within seconds I knew it was American Brilliant. Once you’ve held the real thing in your hands, you’ll never be in doubt about the difference again!

You don’t need to be a serious collector to fall in love with American Brilliant and EAPG. Several pieces will lend instant authenticity and richness to traditional décor. A single bowl or pitcher can give a sleek, contemporary room a dramatic focal point. And cut or pressed glass is the perfect choice for those whose taste runs to eclectic and “found” items.

If you love learning about antiques as much as I do, follow the blog so you won’t miss the next article.
And enjoy the hunt!

Advertisements

About sarathurston

I'm a marketing communications writer who also loves antiques and collectibles. You can find my shop on Etsy at http://www.etsy.com/shop/JanvierRoad
This entry was posted in Antiques, Etsy, Glass and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to Is it Pressed Glass or Cut Glass?

  1. Rosemary says:

    Thank you for this article. It helped me alot to understand the difference.
    Rosemary

  2. At my very first auction, a wise old one told me, “Never pay more than the thing is worth to YOU…” I have yet to find her advice “lacking…” If you love something, the pedigree does not matter. It is better to live your own life, and fill your days with your own delights!

  3. Eric Nelson says:

    I have a glass ferner with a hobstars and daisy pattern similar to Mckee Innovation, but I am pretty sure it is not, because it lacks the characteristic octagonal buttons. Is there a way I could se you pictures and get your thoughts on who may have made it?

  4. Pingback: Pressed and Cut Glass Were Never Meant to be Shabby Chic. | Janvier Road: Where old becomes exciting and new

  5. Pingback: Not all carnival glass is…well, carnivally-looking. | Janvier Road: Where old becomes exciting and new

  6. Pingback: Tackling the Tecs: McKee’s 18 most famous patterns. | Janvier Road: Where old becomes exciting and new

  7. Pingback: McKee’s “Innovation”: Glass that was truly ahead of its time. | Janvier Road: Where old becomes exciting and new

  8. Pingback: Elegant Glass: In a class by itself. | Janvier Road: Where old becomes exciting and new

  9. Pingback: The Museum of American Glass: A celebration of America’s first industry. | Janvier Road: Where old becomes exciting and new

  10. Pingback: Trendspotting: Anchor Hocking’s “Wexford” Pattern | Janvier Road: Where old becomes exciting and new

  11. Pingback: Is it Pressed Glass or Cut Glass? | From the desk of Sara Thurston

  12. sarathurston says:

    That’s one reason I’ve saved my glass for last (to sell on Etsy). I have BOXES of the stuff, and I think most of it is EAPG, but I’d hate to call it something that it isn’t. I think it’s time for another visit to Wheaton Village. HAHAHA!
    Sara

  13. kathy says:

    Thank you for explaining the differences….I also struggle with this!

I'd love to hear your thoughts (and corrections)!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s